Will Qantas now take the Social Business Leap?

When Qantas management suddenly grounded their fleet world-wide, to force a conclusion to months of union action, it provided a great case study in social media. Days later it was finally tallied that 110,000 passengers had been directly effected. That’s a lot of passengers, relatives and friends to spread the bad news! How did all this pan out in social media and what does some social business intelligence tell us?

Asher Moses at Stuff.nz quickly wrote a piece “Qantas rapped for bad social media service” covering some communications challenges, and at Social Mediology Kate vanderVoort wrote a comprehensive assessment of the first 36 hours and how things could have been done better – Qantas: The ‘Unliking’ of an Australian Icon.

To their credit someone from the depths of the storm in social media in Qantas – Cara Pring – responded to Kate vanderVoort’s post. Cara provided an internal perspective on their modus operandi and why certain decisions were made. Very interesting reading as it showed that the Qantas social team were fully aware of most issues but in essence had to make resource allocation decisions which left some issues hanging.

A quick search shows many other posts, mostly concentrating on the qualitative aspects and the operational events, often with recommendations.

iGo2 has undertaken an empirical review using our social business intelligence tools – (see below, or here on Slideshare) – and it illustrates the many challenges facing Qantas. These range from customer defection, compensation, customer service to more generally brand satisfaction.

However from our point of view the biggest single challenge is a more strategic one, and it is this:

Does Qantas wish to move from being a social brand, to a social business?

We use “social business” in the Michael Brito sense, as below (presentation Slide 16).

From Social Brand to Social Enterprise thx to Michael Brito

This shift is a major change. It requires executive management to acknowledge that social is a key channel not only for risk management and brand protection and operations support, but also for building more enduring customer relationships, loyalty, and discovering those service enhancements that really add value.

It requires a cultural change program, and resources to do that, and then it requires ongoing resources and attention to make in an integral part of the way business is done.

We’ll be watching with interest to see how committed Qantas becomes to transforming itself into a social business as a platform for recovering from the aftermath of the recent events.

How far do you think Qantas should go, and will go, in becoming a social business?

Walter @adamson

Optimized with InboundWriter
  • Matt

    Thanks for this Walter.

    I am endeavouring to suggest some options for Cara’s issues, which she raises on Kate’s site here:

    http://www.socialmediology.com.au/qantas-unliking-australian-icon/#comment-71

    My first post is here:

    http://www.socialmediology.com.au/qantas-unliking-australian-icon/#comment-80

    Cheers,
    Matt

    • http://walteradamson.com Walter Adamson

      Thanks Matt. In your post you discuss the issue of Qantas deleting posts from their FB wall and I agree in deciding to do this transparency should be a primary objective. Otherwise unnecessary fires start which take time and effort to quell.

      Walter @adamson

      • Matt

        Thanks Walter. I’ve been meaning to deal with the other issues that she raised, but finding the time has been a struggle — I guess that social media’s a full-time job; perhaps that’s a lesson that’s QF has learned, although the #qantasluxury debacle demonstrates otherwise!

        http://www.socialmediology.com.au/qantas-sequel-retweet/

  • Tom McMahon

    Great post. It is interesting to see management slowly but surely wrapping their heads around the fact that social media engagement is a serious issue.

    Your readers may also be interested in the sentiment analysis of tweets that I performed. You can check out the post on my blog:

    http://blog.thmcmahon.com/2011/graph-negative-reaction-on-twitter-to-qantas-lockout/

    • http://walteradamson.com Walter Adamson

      Thanks Tom, as you said on your post, influence is a key issue in understanding how to engage with different people and groups. Walter

  • http://www.smartsocialmedia.com.au smartselling

    Walter,
    Whilst I think the notion of Qantas maturing into a social business is admirable, I simply don’t believe it is going to happen until the business regenerates the board of directors and hires a truly inspirational leader.

    International speaker Marcus Child noted in September during his visit to Australia as a guest of The Executive Connection that 80-90% of employee behaviour is influenced by three key factors – what the leader attends to, measures, rewards; how the leader responds to critical incidents; and leader role modelling/coaching. As Marcus went on to explain, it’s the language the leader users that sets the culture, attitude, and level of engagement of the workforce.

    In light of this I simply don’t see how Qantas can ever evolve into a social business along the lines of a Zappo’s or Best Buy, or the hundreds of businesses around the world who have become social and enjoy an environment rich with engagement and passion from all stakeholders.

    Nothing against Joyce – but it’s hard to look past the evidence around his language and the focus of the board. Qantas is being led by a group of people who are 100% focused on financial performance and as far as I can tell, customer satisfaction, employee engagement, brand value etc are not metrics to which they subscribe or believe can or will deliver the financial performance that their shareholders demand.

    • http://walteradamson.com Walter Adamson

      Mark,

      Thanks for a very useful comment. I agree with your assessment of what is needed, but not necessarily that it could not happen under Alan Joyce. There would have to be many changes, as you suggest, but he’s not to be underestimated in my opinion. He’s undertaking his own powerful change program at the moment, using his chosen method. In the hierarchy of corporate needs this no doubt demands his whole attention. But I’m sure that he’s capable of shifting that attention and making changes which could support a social business engagement with customers should he choose to do so.

      Walter @adamson